students4reform.com
Search this website:
Guestbook

Democrats
  Manhattan
  Monroe County
  Montgomery County
  Oneida County
  Onondaga County
  Ontario County
  Orange County
  Queens County
  Rockland County
  Schenectady County
  Suffolk County
  Sullivan County
  Ulster County
  Westchester County

Republicans
  Bronx County
  Broome County
  Cayuga County
  Nassau County
  Onondaga County
  Putnam County
  Queens County
  Rockland County
  Wayne County
  Westchester County




This message is brought to you by our student interns from high schools and colleges including NYU, Dartmouth, Harvard, Rutgers, MIT, Cornell, RPI, the University of Michigan and Yale, and attorneys Charles Juntikka, Dan Wolf and Craig Heller.
Home Democrats Republicans Contact Us Get Involved
Announcements Contribute
The Pluses and Minuses of Silver's Record
on Political Corruption Reform or
Why You Should Vote Against Sheldon Silver

Minus 1

SILVER FOISTS
SHAM GIFT BAN
LAW ON THE PUBLIC
Click on the New York Times Editorial dated January 18, 2000 entitled:
Gift Games in Albany

Here is an excerpt:
"Mr. Silver refused to go along with a gift ban after the Senate majority leader, Joseph Bruno, a Republican, had boldly persuaded his chamber to pass a bill that included several useful restrictions on gifts. Mr. Silver wanted to keep the Knicks and Rangers tickets flowing, so Mr. Pataki dropped his support for gift reform in exchange for Mr. Silver's agreement to drop another reform that Mr. Pataki did not like. The net result was a halfhearted ethics overhaul that did not fundamentally threaten Albany's pervasive culture of influence-peddling."

For the full article, go to the New York Times Website and type the following in the 365-Day Archive Search: "Gift Games in Albany"



Minus 2

Leader Silver Gives Away $400 Million In City Dollars To The Suburbs In Losing Cause
Last May, Speaker Silver tried to win commuter votes for a Democratic candidate in the suburbs by cutting the commuter tax. It didn't work. The Republican candidate won. Now the City is out $400 million annually for years to come.
Mayor Koch was so incensed that Democratic Speaker Silver gave away our tax dollars, he considered running against Silver himself!

Click on Mayor Ed Koch's column in the Daily News dated May 28, 1999:
Commuter-Tax Killers Should Be Voted Out

Here is an excerpt:
"J'accuse Assembly Speaker Sheldon Silver of committing high crimes and misdemeanors, namely treason, against the people of New York City. It was Silver who made possible the devastating repeal of the city's commuter tax, whose death warrant Governor Pataki signed yesterday.
In a vain attempt to assist the Democratic candidate in a Rockland County Senate race, Silver joined forces with the State Senate Majority Leader Joe Bruno, who wanted to aide the Republican candidate."

Click on Mayor Ed Koch's column in the Daily News dated August 6, 1999:
Time to Throw Albany Rascals Out of Office

Here is an excerpt:
"In New York, we have Legislature so brazen and unresponsive to its constituents that 25 Assembly Democrats and four Senate Democrats, all from New York City, voted to eliminate the commuter tax, which will cost the city $380 million annually.
Each Assembly member, led by Speaker Sheldon Silver (D-Manhattan), shamelessly and hypocritically claims the vote was in the best interest of the city and expects to be relected by the very people he or she betrayed."



Minus 3

A Majority of the
Assembly Wants To
Get Rid of Our State's
"Leader" System-
BUT
"Leader" Silver Will Not
Even Allow The Assembly
To Vote On The Bill
In New York State, just two "leaders" of the State Assembly and State Senate have complete control of the rules. The leaders control the fates of all of their fellow legislators. If other lawmakers want something for their constituents or a help on an issue or a committee chair, they must obey the leader.

Most states and the United States Congress don't have a "leader" system. They have a conference system.

This makes sense because the genius of democracy is that group decisions are better decisions.

Assemblywoman Sandra Galef and State Senator Richard Dollinger have introduced a conference bill. The vast majority of Assemblymembers have co-sponsored the bill, and "Leader" Sheldon Silver will not even allow a vote on the conference bill.

One man should not be the law.

For more information about this issue, click here for the article from the Albany Time Union dated June 7, 1999, entitled

Rank and File Push Legislative Reform
Search for "Rank and File Push Legislative Reform"

Archive of Print Stories on S4R

NY Times Story
Students Put Pressure on Legislators
by Winnie Hu

Teen People
Election Issue- Students4Reform
by Michelle Hainer

NY Daily News
"Students Teach Good Government"
Editorial

NY Daily News
"Free Calls To Albany Take Their Toll" by Jim Dwyer

Albany Times Union
Students Launch Ads Criticizing State Lawmakers
Story by Lara Jakes

NY Newsday
"Putting Mouth Where Money Is"
by Matthew Cox

The Troy Record
Anti-reform Lawmakers Hit with Attack Ads
Story by Kevin Hogan

GANNET NEWS SERVICE
[Westchester Journal News] "Legislators Who Blocked Ban On Gifts Can Expect 'Negative Mailings,' Reform Group Promises"
by Kyle Hughes

Albany Times Union
Coalition Presses for Strengthened Lobbying Law
Story by Jay Jochnowitz

The Legislative Gazette
Lobby Law Called Cheesy
Story by Timothy Currie

NY Times Story
A Crusade for $100 Campaign Gifts
by Vivian Toy

The Daily Gazette of Schenectady
Group Takes Tonko to Task Over Ballot Reform Position
Story by William F. Hammond Jr.

Rochester Chronicle
Lobby Reformer Takes Aim At New Targets

Albany Times Union
A Story of Pockets and Privilege
Story by Dan Lynch

Other Articles On Corruption

NY Times Exposes Corruption By Gifts To 60 Albany Politicians
Story by Clifford Levy

NY Observer
NY Lawmakers Take (And Take and Take) Gifts From Lobbyists
Story by Andrea Bernstein

Troy Record
Campaign Funds Used For Pool Cover Debated
Story by Kevin Hogan


Gov. George Pataki
(800) 371-0555
Took $2000 in tobacco contributions

Hon. Sheldon Silver
(888) 894-3737
(Ask for Dan Conviser)
Took $2500 in tobacco contributions

Silver's Sham Gift Ban Bill

Sen. Joe Bruno
(888) 894-4652
(Ask for Mike Avella)
Took $3500 in tobacco contributions

Sen. Bruno’s Flawed Gift Ban Bill Loopholes





Home
Top of Page

students4reform.com